![]() | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| | Media criticism over 'harassment' of Time journalist
The Indian government's bid to haul up Time journalist Alex Perry, the author of an unflattering article on Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, has sections of the media crying foul. For my part, I tried. But I could hardly find a “full interview”! All what I read is a long story written by the assumed interviewer of the Palestinian leader, Akiva Eldar! Inside the story, were slyly scattered hither and thither some extracts from Arafat’s assumed declarations. But of a “full interview”, I have seen none! So what’s all that fuss about?
The resentment at the evident "victimisation" of Perry, who has been asked to appear before the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) on a charge of keeping two passports, has been topped by Vajpayee's scathing attack on a "sensationalist" and irresponsible media. Reputed columnist and MP Kuldip Nayar expressed disgust at what he termed an act of vengeance. "I haven't seen such blatant hounding before," he remarked, "I condemn the action against Perry from all angles." Nayar conceded that Vajpayee's remarks on the media's inclination towards the sensational might have been general and not half untrue. "But that is different from Perry's harassment." Perry's story on Vajpayee, entitled "Asleep at the Wheel", painted the prime minister as a feeble, pill-popping septuagenarian with an eating and drinking problem, implying he was an "unusual" candidate to control a nuclear arsenal. According to former editor B.G. Verghese, governments are usually sensitive about criticism. "All governments bask in the glow of media praise and bristle at criticism." The Time article was "rather silly", but it did not call for harassment by the state, he added. New Delhi took the article as an affront and shot off an angry rejoinder terming it as baseless and motivated. And, soon afterwards, Perry was pulled up for allegedly possessing more than one passport and asked to appear before the FRRO under the home ministry. Usha Rai, senior journalist and deputy director of the Press Institute of India (PII), said: "Not that I support what he wrote, but he is definitely being hounded and harassed by the government, which wants to make his life difficult." External affairs ministry officials, however, denied Perry was harassed. "I don't believe there has been any harassment. As far as investigation is concerned it is in the purview of the home ministry," a spokesperson said. Rai also protested Vajpayee's criticism of the media. "They keep doing this - they also accused the media of 'biased reporting' of the Gujarat violence." Not long ago, the Vajpayee government was equally annoyed when the media heaped blame on the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in Gujarat for abetting sectarian violence in the state since February-end. Other foreign correspondents in India cautiously avoided comment on Perry's questioning. New York Times' award- winning correspondent Barry Bearak, said: "We have a policy of not commenting on controversial issues like this." Tarun Tejpal, editor of news Web site Tehelka, hit out at the government move. "It is a joke -- another illustration of the growing intolerance in the government," he told IANS. "They are being incredibly immature." Tejpal, whose tehelka.com and its investors have faced various government action ever since the Web site broke a defence scandal involving the top brass of defence forces and the government, said "harassment" of Perry was scandalous. Tejpal pointed out that heads of state in countries such as the U.S. and Britain were constantly lampooned. Journalists said harassment of the media and attempts to browbeat them have been witnessed in previous regimes too. In 1990, then prime minister V.P. Singh's deputy, Devi Lal, was livid at being called the "rogue elephant" by The Economist. Copies of the magazine were seized as the government tried to prevent it from sale in India. The protestors chose to ignore -- or did not know -- the fact that a rogue elephant is one that breaks away from the herd. Before this, the Indira Gandhi regime unleashed most draconian restrictions on the press, including cutting off their electricity and printing press, during the Emergency of 1975-77 when thousands of political opponents were imprisoned.
|