Hindi media people spreading Urdu and English rather than Hindi in its all forums

The sad state of affairs at the Bharatiya media leads to the larger question of journalistic ethics and integrity. The English-language and even vernacular press and all sorts of Hindi media in Bharat and in foreign countries are politically correct and opportunistic. These are commercial commodity or propaganda machinery for inimical forces of Hindus without ideals. It has no credibility among the informed public because it is wedded to a secularist fundamentalism and are of mental slavery that is at odds with the spiritual ethos of the Bharatiya people. At the same time it is able to shape public opinion to some extent in such a manner, which benefits politically from its morally criminal position of untruth and put poison in the minds and brains of Hindus.

In Hindi media, there are many such people who are more interested in promoting Urdu and English languages rather than Hindi. All sorts of Hindi media people are under the influence of Urdu and English. Media may be in print, broadcast or entertainment like Hindi films and Hindi TV programs are full of Urdu and English words.

Here is some glimpse of the behavior of Hindi journalists

On December 1, 2005 a Pakistani journalist came on the Hindi service of Radio German. He was speaking very difficult Urdu. Then Pushp Ranjan, a journalist of Radio German Hindi service was asking questions from that Pakistani journalist. Pushp Ranjan also started speaking very, very difficult Urdu language for asking questions in his Hindi service. The Muslim / Pakistani journalists are not as shameless and slave as Hindi correspondents that they would start speaking Hindi in Hindi service. They would keep speaking in Urdu even for Hindi services. They speak so difficult Urdu that it is difficult to understand for only Hindi knowing people. Moreover there is no need for so much Urdu in Hindi service.

Under such circumstances what is the point in having Hindi service, if you Hindi media people are to speak and broadcast such difficult Urdu in your Hindi service?

In Hindi services, listeners expect to hear pure Hindi, not Urdu or English.

When a request was made to media people please translate in proper Hindi what Muslim correspondents say and then broadcast and please do not put any Muslim/ Pakistan correspondent on the air in your Hindi service, then they made angry response.

----- Original Message -----

From: pushp ranjan

To: Mohan Gupta

Sent: Friday, December 02, 2005 6:06 AM

Subject: stop abusive words

Don’t guide us, whom we should employ and whom we should not.

Learn some Urdu words than you would be able to enjoy the language.

Hindi correspondents are not shameless and slave, as you said.

I think only mentally sick people use these types of abusive words.

Pushp Ranjan, a journalist in Hindi service of Radio German Hindi service does not speak pure Hindi for the Hindi service. He not only speaks Urdu in its Hindi service, he is so rude to advise his Hindi listeners to learn Urdu for understanding Hindi in Hindi programs.

Who the hell are Hindi journalists to advise his Hindi listeners to learn Urdu for understanding and enjoying Hindi programs? There are many people who enjoy more Hindi than Urdu and English. Why Hindi listener people should learn Urdu and English to please people like Pushp Ranjan and other Hindi media people.

People like Pushp Ranjan are most unworthy and unsuitable for Hindi services. They should be in Urdu services rather than in Hindi services.

Would Radio German or any other media centre pay attention to know what kind of its staff they are having and what they are presenting to Hindi audience.

----- Original Message -----

From: Dave Muir

To: pushp ranjan
You are doing it again....

Persistence on wrong reasons does not help you at all.

You must realize that I and other Hindi loving people are not telling you how to do your job or feel about the language as we do. You have to understand that you work in Hindi Radio and what your audiences expect from you to do your job accordingly. And more importantly, what your job requirements are. The more you argue back the worst it looks on your part.

How much clearly you would like someone to tell you? You are wrong. Go ask your own guru's......... anyone you have respected for.

You explain about your name, Pushp Ranjan, in order to correct me. Which, again does not go with your argument? Pushpranjan is one word that means bee.

I mentioned about your name which is a Pure Hindi name. Do you agree with that??? What it means does not matter here.
Now our argument here is about "A PERSON WHO WORKS IN "HINDI" MEDIA, IS OBLIGATED TO SPEAK WHICH LANGUAGE"????

Your argument is that lots of Muslim people have written books using Hindi language.

Arre Bhayya,

If Muslims who were born in Bharat and speaking in Hindi & writing in Hindi, so what knowledge you have gain by reading their book. That also proves my point, which is,

A real Bharatiya should speak in REAL National Language for the sake of our UNITY.

They (all Muslim writers) must be respected for their work because they did what's right for a proud person.

Will you argue with that too!!!

I try my best.... but my best is not good enough for you.

Your best is to do what is popular and not what is right.

By the way, if I may ask, which part of India you are originally from.

That might make me understand your point of views that why you are so against of speaking your National Language?

pushp ranjan wrote:

"Listen,

I can teach you for years and years.....

Stop sending mail to me.

I dont have time to go through the garbage."

Bare Dubly-Patly vastu hain aap.

If you believe you are doing a justice to your job then:

You first show your knowledge in Hindi by working in Hindi Radio.
When your audience ask you to do justice to what you have been getting paid from your JOB, do not argue but correct it right away and apologise for not noticing this by yourself first.
You must not stay of course on defending your stand for your wrong choices, picking up Urdu mixed Hindi and broadcasting it on Radio where you are working at present.
You must appreciate Shri Mohan ji's sentiments about the national language of Bharat "HINDI". You should commend Shri Mohan ji's time for at least letting you know about your shortcomings.
So do the right thing or as I asked you earlier, if you love Urdu so much(which you do not) , show it to the world by changing your HINDI NAME TO A MUSLIM ONE and working for a Urdu Radio Service. And for God's sake show some class for working in a Hindi Radio Stations.
Aap ka ek Shubh Chintak,

Digvijay

pushp ranjan wrote:

I feel pity of you. Try to enhance your knowledge, wide your vision and

read Wali Dakhani, Amir Khusro, Bulleshah, Rahim, Mir Taqi Mir, Nazir Akbarabadi, Nazir Banarasi, Faiz and even Ahmed Faraz ; they all use Hindi words in their work.

From: Dave Muir

By the way AAP KAHAN SE KUD PADE?

My email (enclosed) to Shri Rajesh Joshi of BBC Hindi service also applies to you as well. If some one is talking to you in Hindi, it is rude to talk back in different language and if you consider yourself an educated one, then being a Bharatiya, you should have the good knowledge of Hindi, our National Language. By using more Urdu words in your vocabulary, shows your depth of limitation. Of course if you are having conversations with Urdu speaking people, you should impress them by your Urdu language.

I have many Pakistani friends and they will prefer not to use any Hindi words even though they understand me well. Have you gone to a Mushaira in Bharat, all poets use pure Urdu words? Why, then no one dare making comments against it. If they are from Bharat, they must use proper language in a proper surrounding (Hindi speaking audience).

How come, our movies carry a message that Ram, Raheem and Jesus are the same God? But in English and Urdu movie maker do not compare this way at all. This is call double standard and we are stupid if we can not even talk about it with our own so called "Media People", who are working in a Hindi Radio or TV. and representing (suppose to) the Hindi language. Suppose, if you are working in an English Media, your job demands you that not only just to speak that language, but to keep on improving your vocabulary in order to use proper language.

And here you are!!! We, as audience, are trying to tell you to improve your Hindi, since you work for Hindi Media (NOT URDU MEDIA) and you are trying hard to prove that you are doing right thing instead of taking the challenge to improve your vocabulary. In simple term, I will call it LAZINESS in your part. Believe me; I know you must be feeling deep pains in your subconscious for not being able to learn the language which provides your livelihood. But what I fail to understand is that you are shamelessly arguing to divert the main subject.

So the advice is same to you too.

Either change your vocabulary (the hard part)

OR

if you love Urdu so much, change the Hindi Media to Urdu Media. By the way "Pushp" and "Rajan" are pure Hindi words. Find a better Urdu name to match with your character.
I hope you are serious about this topic.

My take on this is, if Hindi has been deemed our National language, then every state in Bharat needs to honor this and learn Hindi is a great language, so sweet, so close to Sanskrit , having the same Devanagiri script . Why can't the Tamilians learn it? They should start doing so in schools itself. Surely the rest of India cannot learn Tamil as the national language? But that is what the Tamilians would want us to do.

Tamilians should be proud of Tamil as I am of Marathi .And I always was ready to learn Hindi which I must admit came easy to me because the script is the same and many words are similar to Hindi and Sanskrit . But Tamil is nowhere close to Sanskrit. It cannot represent the rest of India.

Bottom line is that Hindi reigns supreme as the national language and all Bharatiyas should be able to speak it.

Hindi needs to be learnt and respected by every child in the schools in Bharat.

Dhanyavaad

dave muir wrote:

For your question:

"By the way AAP KAHAN SE KUD PADE?"

BTW, I am also a member of HindiNJ Group, which has more then 1200 members and Shri Mohan often writes in HidiNJ Forum.
Ise liye main beech main Kood pada. Lekin aap ko to achcha lagna chahiye. Kiyon ki lagbhag 1200 log aap ke bare main padh rahein hain, ki aap Bharat ke desh ki Bhasha aur Hindi Media ke saath niyay nahein kar rahe hain.

Mohan Gupta wrote

Sh Rajeshji of BBC Hindi service and other Hindi media people ,

If you have got so much love for Urdu, then why work in Hindi department? You should be in Urdu department rather than in Hindi deparment.You have said in excellent way that Hindus are full of traitors and they are ready to make Hindus again slave of Muslims or Christians.

You deserve to be head of traitors of Hindus. You said it nicely.

Hindi Media people spread more Urdu than Hindi

From: Dave Muir

To: Rajesh Joshi of BBC Hindi service

"Julaam Bharat ki julaam sunthane" !!!

It would have sounded much better, if you had said that speaking Urdu sound good but one must know Hindi pretty well (as an Indian), then only, one can dare making a statement like that

Remember, it is Hindi which has the title of being the National Language and not Urdu. (Please correct your general knowledge about Bharat.

So, decide about your limitation on picking up easy thing in life ... not the right one though. If you work BBC Hindi services, in Radio German Hindi service, or any other Hindi media you must speak or try your best to pretend speaking in good Hindi.

By the way, if these are your real views then please have the courage to change your name to a Muslim one (sound good & blend in with your character) and ask them to transfer you in a Urdu department as Sri Mohan ji has suggested you earlier.

Hindi magazines like Meri Saheli, Grah Sobha, Hindi edition of India Today are some of the worst Hindi magazines in using Urdu and English words in its Hindi magazines. In these magazines there are more Urdu and English words than Hindi words. Urdu and English words are written in Nagri script. Meri Saheli and Grah Sobha are Hindi magazines are meant for females. Looking at these magazines no wonder that all female journalists in all types of Hindi media get only Taleem and only very few females get Shiksha for the Hindi services. Hindi Shiksha would make all Hindi journalists worthy in working Hindi fields. To understand and enjoy Hindi magazine, one has to learn Urdu and English languages nowadays.

To show the glimpse what kind of Hindi is written in Grah Sobha and Meri Saheli, some recent examples are available from the recent editions of these magazines:

Examples of the type of Hindi written from monthly Hindi magazine Grah Sobha (published by Delhi Press)

Career wife, Fati Skin. Personality Grooming, Hydro manicure and pedicure, modern ba trendy nail art, Firozi stretchable sweater, sleeveless short pullover, office romance cards par holidays, T-shirt with embroidery, delicious cake,

In another Delhi Publication, Sarita, the heading one of the articles is Back Paan which concerns with health problem.

In Meri Sahli, published by pioneer publications from Mumbai, the glimpse of some headings are:

Bridal Beauty tips, Long distance marriage, Bridal hair style, Push baak Therapy, Sex problems etc.

These all heading quoted above were written in nagri script.

All of you Hindi media people always use many such Urdu words in Hindi like

Tahat, Muddha, Nakaam, Isteefa, Mahoul, Tahat, Matahat, Muddha, Jimmedari, Kabool etc.

These are all Urdu words. Without fail all Hindi journalist use these words. In fact all sorts of Hindi media people use several thousands Urdu words in Hindi for which proper Hindi words are available. Would you all Hindi journalist people please let me know which school of journalism teaches such Urdu words as form of Hindi?

For Push Ranjanji, Rajesh Joshi and other Hindi media people

Do you know what responsibilities are involved in doing a job where you are to deal with public? In such jobs people have to bear abuses and take brickbats if job is not done properly.

If you are in media service you cannot ask anybody to stop contacting you or commenting upon you.

Before taking a job, try to know what would be your responsibilities and who have rights to abuse you.

We are your listeners and if you are not providing the material which we want to listen we have every right to abuse you Hindi media people and also complain to your boss and even to his boss as the case may be.

Wake up and do your job properly, otherwise quit the job saying that you are unfit for the job.

---------------------